Fed Set for Rate Cut Amid Historic Internal Split: A Pause Ahead?

The consensus machine is broken. As the Federal Reserve's rate-setting committee gathers in Washington this week (Dec 9-10), Chair Jerome Powell faces his toughest leadership test yet. The agenda? A potential third straight interest rate cut.

But unlike previous meetings where decisions were nearly unanimous, the 19-member committee is now "sharply divided". Caught between stubborn inflation and a weakening job market—and flying blind without official data due to the government shutdown—the Fed is navigating a dense economic fog.

With dissent brewing from both "Hawks" (who want higher rates) and "Doves" (who want faster cuts), Wall Street is bracing for a "Hawkish Cut": a rate reduction today, followed by a warning signal that the party might be over for a while.

1. The "Convoluted" Economy: Why The Split?

Usually, the playbook is simple: if inflation is high, raise rates. If jobs are scarce, cut rates. Today, the Fed is facing both at once, creating a policy nightmare.

The Case for Cutting (The Doves)

The labor market is flashing red. ADP data for November showed companies shed 32,000 jobs, and major firms are announcing layoffs. The unemployment rate has ticked up to 4.4%, a four-year high. Powell and his allies argue that waiting too long to cut rates could crash the economy into a recession.

The Case for Holding (The Hawks)

Inflation hasn't disappeared. Officials like Jeffrey Schmid (Kansas City Fed) argue that cutting rates now risks reigniting price rises. They believe the current inflation uptick is sticky, not temporary, and warrants caution.

2. The "Hawkish Cut": What Does It Mean?

Most economists expect a compromise known as a "Hawkish Cut".

This strategy buys time. By January, the Fed hopes to have three months of backlogged data (currently delayed by the shutdown) to make a clearer decision.

3. The Politics: Powell vs. Trump vs. The Board

This meeting isn't just about economics; it's about power. Chair Powell's term ends in May, and President Trump has already signaled he would replace him, potentially with Kevin Hassett.

• Internal Dissent: Governor Stephen Miran, a Trump appointee, is pushing for a larger half-point cut, arguing the Fed is behind the curve.
• External Pressure: Trump has relentlessly attacked Powell, calling him a "clown" and threatening to fire him.
• Powell's Legacy: Despite the noise, influential members like John Williams (NY Fed) have rallied behind Powell, signaling that the "Chair's power" is still intact to push this cut through.

4. Market Impact: What Should Investors Do?

A divided Fed creates volatility. As Governor Christopher Waller warned, if a vote is tight (e.g., 7-5), markets lose confidence because a single flip could change future policy.

5. The Data Vacuum: Flying Blind

Adding to the complexity is the government shutdown, which has delayed official jobs and inflation reports. The Fed is making decisions based on private data (like ADP) and regional surveys, which are less reliable.

This lack of clarity is exactly why a "Pause" after December is likely. As economist Kathy Bostjancic notes, the Fed may cut now but signal they are "on pause for a while" until the data fog clears.

---

Final Verdict: A Delicate Balancing Act

Jerome Powell is walking a tightrope. Cut too aggressively, and inflation roars back. Cut too slowly, and the unemployment line grows. This week's decision will likely be a compromise—a cut to satisfy the labor market worries, wrapped in tough talk to satisfy the inflation hawks.

Disclaimer: Central bank policies are complex and subject to change. This article is for informational purposes only.