Bata India Limited vs Voltas Limited
Compared on live NSE market data
Bata India Limited vs Voltas Limited: which is better?
Bata India Limited (BATAINDIA) and Voltas Limited (VOLTAS) are both listed on the National Stock Exchange, and both operate in Consumer Durables — so this is a like-for-like comparison rather than two unrelated businesses. Everything below is computed from the official NSE daily Bhavcopy: closing price, 52-week range, traded value and, where reported, valuation metrics.
On one-year price return Voltas Limited is ahead, -19.29% against -31.85%. Put concretely: ₹1,00,000 put into Voltas Limited a year ago would be worth about ₹80,706 today on price alone, against roughly ₹68,147 in Bata India Limited — a difference of ₹12,560. Dividends are not included in either figure.
Relative to their own trading ranges, Voltas Limited sits 29.2% below its 52-week high while Bata India Limited is 33.3% below its own. Both are therefore at broadly similar points in their yearly cycle, so neither looks obviously beaten down relative to the other.
Measured from the other end, Bata India Limited trades 6.6% above its 52-week low (range ₹599.6–₹958.75) and Voltas Limited 17.2% above its own (₹930.5–₹1,539). A wider band generally means a more volatile stock over the past year.
Trailing P/E is not available for either company in our NSE dataset, so a like-for-like valuation comparison is not possible here. Check the company's latest reported earnings before judging either on price alone.
Liquidity differs too: Voltas Limited traded about ₹267.0 Cr on the latest session against ₹3.7 Cr for Bata India Limited. Daily turnover below roughly ₹5 Cr is thin for a retail investor — large orders can move the price against you, and exiting quickly during a fall is harder. That is a practical risk separate from anything the valuation shows.
None of these figures identifies a "better" stock on its own, and they frequently disagree — the cheaper name is often cheaper for a reason, and the stronger one-year performer may already have priced in its good news. What the numbers do is narrow the question: if the two look similar on returns and valuation, liquidity and position in the 52-week band become the deciding factors. Read them alongside the companies' actual results, debt and sector outlook.
Figures are end-of-day from the NSE Bhavcopy and may be delayed. This comparison is informational and is not investment advice — consider a SEBI-registered adviser before buying either.
Key takeaways
- Voltas Limited has the stronger 1-year return (-19.29% vs -31.85%).
- Both stocks are down over the past year — this is a comparison of smaller and larger losses.
- Voltas Limited is closer to its 52-week high (29.2% below vs 33.3%).
- Bata India Limited trades thinly (₹3.7 Cr/day) — exits may be harder.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which has given better returns — Bata India Limited or Voltas Limited?
Over the last year, Voltas Limited returned more (Bata India Limited: -31.85%, Voltas Limited: -19.29%). These are price returns from NSE closing data and exclude dividends. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Is Bata India Limited or Voltas Limited closer to its 52-week high?
Voltas Limited is closer, trading 29.2% below its 52-week high against 33.3% for Bata India Limited. Being near a high is not automatically bullish, nor is a large drawdown automatically a bargain — both need the underlying business context.
Which is more liquid — Bata India Limited or Voltas Limited?
Voltas Limited, with roughly ₹267.0 Cr of traded value in the latest session against ₹3.7 Cr for Bata India Limited. Higher turnover generally means tighter spreads and easier exits, which matters most if you ever need to sell in a hurry.
Should I invest in Bata India Limited or Voltas Limited?
Neither is universally better — it depends on your horizon, risk appetite and what you already hold. Use the returns, valuation, 52-week position and liquidity above to narrow the question, then check each company's latest results and debt before deciding. A single stock should form only part of a diversified portfolio.
Can I hold both Bata India Limited and Voltas Limited?
Yes, though be aware both operate in Consumer Durables. Holding two companies from the same industry gives you less diversification than it appears, since the same sector-wide events tend to move both in the same direction.
Price, turnover and 52-week data from the official NSE daily Bhavcopy; returns computed from our own stored daily history. Figures are not adjusted for stock splits or bonus issues. Analysis computed from that data. Not financial advice — always do your own research before investing.