Hindalco Industries Limited vs Vedanta Limited
Compared on live NSE market data
Hindalco Industries Limited vs Vedanta Limited: which is better?
Hindalco Industries Limited (HINDALCO) and Vedanta Limited (VEDL) are both listed on the National Stock Exchange, and both operate in Metals & Mining — so this is a like-for-like comparison rather than two unrelated businesses. Everything below is computed from the official NSE daily Bhavcopy: closing price, 52-week range, traded value and, where reported, valuation metrics.
On one-year price return Hindalco Industries Limited is ahead, +8.58% against -56.73%. Put concretely: ₹1,00,000 put into Hindalco Industries Limited a year ago would be worth about ₹1,08,579 today on price alone, against roughly ₹43,266 in Vedanta Limited — a difference of ₹65,312. Dividends are not included in either figure.
Relative to their own trading ranges, Hindalco Industries Limited sits 18.4% below its 52-week high while Vedanta Limited is 67.0% below its own. That is a wide divergence: one is trading near the top of its yearly range and the other well off it. A large drawdown can mark either a buying opportunity or a business whose outlook has deteriorated — the number alone does not distinguish between them.
Measured from the other end, Hindalco Industries Limited trades 14.8% above its 52-week low (range ₹835.95–₹1,176) and Vedanta Limited 18.2% above its own (₹221.6–₹795). A wider band generally means a more volatile stock over the past year.
Trailing P/E is not available for either company in our NSE dataset, so a like-for-like valuation comparison is not possible here. Check the company's latest reported earnings before judging either on price alone.
Liquidity differs too: Hindalco Industries Limited traded about ₹858.1 Cr on the latest session against ₹253.1 Cr for Vedanta Limited. Both see enough daily volume that an ordinary retail order should execute without materially moving the price.
None of these figures identifies a "better" stock on its own, and they frequently disagree — the cheaper name is often cheaper for a reason, and the stronger one-year performer may already have priced in its good news. What the numbers do is narrow the question: if the two look similar on returns and valuation, liquidity and position in the 52-week band become the deciding factors. Read them alongside the companies' actual results, debt and sector outlook.
Figures are end-of-day from the NSE Bhavcopy and may be delayed. This comparison is informational and is not investment advice — consider a SEBI-registered adviser before buying either.
Key takeaways
- Hindalco Industries Limited has the stronger 1-year return (+8.58% vs -56.73%).
- Hindalco Industries Limited is closer to its 52-week high (18.4% below vs 67.0%).
Frequently Asked Questions
Which has given better returns — Hindalco Industries Limited or Vedanta Limited?
Over the last year, Hindalco Industries Limited returned more (Hindalco Industries Limited: +8.58%, Vedanta Limited: -56.73%). These are price returns from NSE closing data and exclude dividends. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Is Hindalco Industries Limited or Vedanta Limited closer to its 52-week high?
Hindalco Industries Limited is closer, trading 18.4% below its 52-week high against 67.0% for Vedanta Limited. Being near a high is not automatically bullish, nor is a large drawdown automatically a bargain — both need the underlying business context.
Which is more liquid — Hindalco Industries Limited or Vedanta Limited?
Hindalco Industries Limited, with roughly ₹858.1 Cr of traded value in the latest session against ₹253.1 Cr for Vedanta Limited. Higher turnover generally means tighter spreads and easier exits, which matters most if you ever need to sell in a hurry.
Should I invest in Hindalco Industries Limited or Vedanta Limited?
Neither is universally better — it depends on your horizon, risk appetite and what you already hold. Use the returns, valuation, 52-week position and liquidity above to narrow the question, then check each company's latest results and debt before deciding. A single stock should form only part of a diversified portfolio.
Can I hold both Hindalco Industries Limited and Vedanta Limited?
Yes, though be aware both operate in Metals & Mining. Holding two companies from the same industry gives you less diversification than it appears, since the same sector-wide events tend to move both in the same direction.
Price, turnover and 52-week data from the official NSE daily Bhavcopy; returns computed from our own stored daily history. Figures are not adjusted for stock splits or bonus issues. Analysis computed from that data. Not financial advice — always do your own research before investing.